P0424 – Heated catalytic converter, bank 1 -temperature below threshold

By Benjamin Jerew (Contact Me)
Last Updated 2016-03-19
ASE Master Tech

Table of Contents

1. What Does Code P0424 Mean?
2. What are the common causes of code P0424 ?
3. What are the symptoms of code P0424 ?
4. How do you troubleshoot code P0424 ?
5. Codes Related to P0424
6. Get Help with P0424

What Does Code P0424 Mean?

“Perfect combustion” should result in harmless emissions, only carbon dioxide (CO₂) and water vapor (H₂O), but “real world” harmful emissions include oxides of nitrogen (NO_X), carbon monoxide (CO), and unburned hydrocarbons (HC), consisting of oil and unburned fuel. Proper maintenance and good driving habits help to reduce emissions, but one more piece of onboard equipment seeks to eliminate them entirely. The three-way catalytic converter (TWC), usually just referred to as “the cat,” combines these harmful emissions with leftover oxygen, getting much closer to the “ideal” perfect-combustion emissions model.

The TWC is part of the exhaust system, perhaps part of the exhaust manifold or installed in the exhaust pipe, and looks like another muffler or resonator. Inside, however, is a metal or ceramic honeycomb material, doped with a soup of chemicals and precious metals, such as aluminum oxide, titanium dioxide, ceria-zirconia, platinum, palladium, cerium, manganese, and copper. When heated by hot exhaust gases, between 600 °F and 1,600 °F, the TWC reduces NO_X to harmless oxygen and nitrogen (O₂ and N₂) and oxidizes CO and HC to produce harmless CO₂ and H₂O.

The engine control module’s (ECM) primary purpose, aside from running the engine, is to reduce harmful emissions as much as possible, and so it constantly monitors the efficiency of the the TWC. The upstream heated oxygen sensors (HO₂S), sometimes referred to as air-fuel ratio (AFR) or lambda sensor, is mainly used to fine-tune air fuel ratio, but the ECM also monitors TWC function by comparing upstream AFR readings to downstream HO₂S readings.

The AFR sensor is constantly switching from rich to lean and back, reflecting ever-changing oxygen content in the exhaust stream. Once the exhaust passes through the catalytic converter, oxygen content should remain steady, by virtue of the TWC’s reduction and oxidation activities. If the ECM detects that there is too much activity downstream, it determines that the catalytic converter is not heating up enough, sets diagnostic trouble code (DTC) P0424, “Heated Catalyst Temperature Below Threshold (Bank 1),” and illuminates the check engine light (CEL).

What are the common causes of code P0424 ?

DTC P0424 may have number of causes. Here are the most common.

• Lack of Maintenance – It does one good to note that the catalytic converter is not a wear item, and should last the life of the vehicle. Unrectified engine problems, such as faulty oxygen sensors or cylinder misfires, for example, can lead to catalyst overheating, over 1,800 °F to 2,500 °F, possible meltdown, and failure. Always maintain your vehicle, use the recommended fluids and parts, and make repairs promptly. Failure to do so can easily lead to catalytic converter damage.
• Lazy Oxygen Sensor – It is possible that, even if an AFR sensor passes the ECM monitor, it may be “lazy,” or reacting slowly. The result is a wider swing of rich and lean, constantly overheating and underheating the catalytic converter, eventually leading to damage. The factory repair manual, or equivalent, should give some kind of specification regarding expected switching times.

What are the symptoms of code P0424 ?

Aside from the CEL, you will most likely not notice any drivability symptoms. Your fuel economy will suffer, however, and your car will be producing higher levels of harmful emissions.

How do you troubleshoot code P0424 ?

Many people jump to the conclusion that the oxygen sensors must be faulty, reasoning that the expensive catalytic converter, with usually run upwards of $1,000, “can’t be” the fault. Keep in mind, however, that the ECM cannot run the catalytic converter monitor unless the oxygen sensor monitors have run and passed.

• That being said, if you see any other DTCs, particularly anything to do with misfires, fuel trims, or oxygen sensors, diagnose and repair those first. Clear all codes and drive the vehicle. If DTC P0424 or any other catalytic converter codes return, then you can proceed with diagnosing the catalytic converter
• First, check for leaks in the exhaust system. If there are any leaks between the engine and the catalytic converter, this can allow excess oxygen into the exhaust stream, pumping more oxygen into the TWC and skewing AFR and HO₂S readings. Make sure you flex the exhaust system, and check around flex joints, gaskets, ball joints, and any rusty spots. Repair as necessary. Again, clear codes and check to see if any codes return.

• Second, the best way to test catalytic converter operation is with a scan tool, with live data streaming. A digital oscilloscope can be just as effective, as you want to compare voltage readings of the upstream and downstream sensors.
  • With the engine idling, the upstream AFR sensor should be switching between high and low voltage, usually 0.5 V and 3.5 V, (1 V HO₂S will switch between 0.2 V and 0.8 V, more or less) depending on manufacturer, and the downstream HO₂S should run around 0.5 V. Retry the test at highway cruising speed, which should force the catalytic converter to heat up. Again, look for fast voltage switching on the upstream sensor, slow or no switching on the downstream sensor.
  • In either test, if the downstream sensor mimics the upstream sensor, chances are that the catalytic converter has been compromised.

Codes Related to P0424

• DTC P0420 Catalyst System Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 1)
• DTC P0421 Warm Up Catalyst Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 1)
• DTC P0422 Main Catalyst Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 1)
• DTC P0423 Heated Catalyst Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 1)
• DTC P0430 Catalyst System Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 2)
• DTC P0431 Warm Up Catalyst Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 2)
• DTC P0432 Main Catalyst Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 2)
• DTC P0433 Heated Catalyst Efficiency Below Threshold (Bank 2)
• DTC P0434 Heated Catalyst Temperature Below Threshold (Bank 2)

Help Us Help You

Please comment below describing your issue as well as the specifics of your vehicle (make, model, year, miles, and engine). To get a detailed, expedited response from a mechanic, please make a $9.99 donation via the payment button below.